Review: 4th-generation iPad
We review the new 4th-generation iPad with Retina Display
At the iPad mini event, Apple did something that it hasn't done in
quite some time: it surprised us. With most of the company's recent
products leaking well before their announcements, the days of being
thrown for a loop at an Apple event appeared to be over. But thrown for a
loop we were, when Apple announced a new 4th-generation iPad.
We knew that a new iPad was coming, but it was supposed to be a new
3rd-generation iPad with a Lightning connector. Instead, we got a new
model with not only the new connector, but updated front-facing cameras,
and a new A6X chip. A modest upgrade, yes; but a much bigger one than
anyone expected.
Now that the iPad 4 is here, is it worth upgrading? Or should you
hold out for the inevitable 5th-generation model? Let's take a look.
Design
It's deja vu, all over again
If you've ever used a 3rd-generation iPad, then you're already
familiar with the 4th-generation iPad's design. The only external
difference is that the older iPad's larger 30-pin port is replaced by
the tiny Lightning port.
Otherwise it's the same aluminum build, tapered back, and 9.4-mm
thickness. Even the weight stays the same, at 653 g (1.44 lbs). The
difference between this iPad and the last is like the jump from the
iPhone 3G to 3GS or iPhone 4 to 4S: it's all on the inside.
Display
The best display in the business hasn't changed at all
Nothing has changed here either. It's the exact same 9.7-inch, 2048 x
1536 Retina Display found in the 3rd-generation iPad. Text looks nearly
like printed paper, photos are crisp and vibrant, and games like
Infinity Blade II and
N.O.V.A. 3 offer an absurd amount of graphical detail.
The only other tablet display that compares to the iPad's is the nearly 300 pixels per inch (PPI) screen found in the
Nexus 10. We'll have to wait to see these two side-by-side, but there's nothing to complain about in this stellar display.
Performance
The iPad 4 blazed through GTA 3
The iPad 4 is only upgraded in one major area, but it's quite an
upgrade. Its A6X chip features a 1.4GHz dual core processor, along with
quad core graphics. Apple promised over twice the performance of the
3rd-generation iPad. This was no bloated claim: the new iPad sizzles.
The iPad 3 never felt slow to me, but it also wasn't noticeably
zippy. The iPad 4 is. If you've used an iPhone 5, expect similar speeds
here. Apps open and close instantly, pictures snap in rapid-fire
fashion, and intensive gaming is flawless. Putting the new tablet
through Geekbench paces yielded a score of 1766, a huge improvement over
the iPad 3's 757.
One of the big places you'll notice the A6X is in loading screens.
Apps and games which previously took several seconds to load are now
ready in less than half of that time.
The new iPad blazed through one of the more processor-intensive
productivity apps, Photoshop Touch. Applying filters, tweaking lighting
levels, and making selections all went much quicker on the
4th-generation iPad. Adjusting selections, which used to be interrupted
by constant processing, now happens almost in real-time. Adobe hasn't
updated its app in any way for the A6X chip, so this boost is without
any help from the software.
If the 3rd-generation iPad doesn't feel slow to you, then you might
want to keep a distance from this 4th-generation model. After using it,
the old one will feel slow.
Cameras
The new(er) iPad's front-facing camera (right) takes much clearer pictures
The front camera was upgraded in the 4th-generation iPad, and it's a
noticeable improvement. It's still only 1.2 MP, but that's significantly
higher than the VGA front shooter in the iPad 3.
As you can see in the above (non-processed) samples, the new front
camera will make your friends look significantly sharper on the 9.7-inch
screen.
The rear camera is basically the same as the one in the iPad 3, but
Apple is advertising the addition of some of the optics from the iPhone
5. You can see below that it isn't a huge difference, but the new camera
does appear to let in a bit more light:
The rear camera is mostly the same, but it does appear to have some improved optics
Wi-Fi
Gizmag's homepage rendered faster, but it was due to the A6X chip, not faster Wi-Fi
Apple claims that the new iPad has improved Wi-Fi capabilities,
supporting dual-band (2.4GHz and 5GHz) 802.11n and channel bonding.
Depending on your connection, you may see faster network speeds.
On the 20Mbps DSL-based network I tested it on, I saw no difference
from the 3rd-generation iPad. Speed tests clocked the 4th-gen. model at
roughly the same speeds. Uploads, downloads, and latency were all in the
same ballpark. Perhaps those with faster home networks will see
improved performance, but I wouldn't recommend basing your purchase on
this.
Software
The App Store is still one of the iPad's biggest advantages
Apart from its Jony Ive-helmed design, the biggest reason to choose the iPad over rivals like
Surface RT
and the Nexus 10 is its software. The App Store has over 275,000 native
tablet apps, many more than any of its competitors. A great computer is
nothing without great software, and the iPad delivers.
The new iPad presently ships with iOS 6, and you can immediately
update it to 6.0.1. Siri, Facebook/Twitter integration, Maps (for better
or worse), and all of the familiar staples of iOS are waiting. For more
detail, you can see our
overview of iOS 6.
Who is it for?
Is it worth upgrading?
When Apple announced the 4th-generation iPad, iPad 3 owners were
furious, as their seven-month-old devices were deemed obsolete. There
is, however, one big problem with this assessment: the 3rd-generation
iPad is far from obsolete. Though the older model is off the market, the
iPad 4 is essentially the same device with some improved guts.
Apart from those obsessed with having the latest-and-greatest (and
those with money to blow), iPad 3 owners don't even need to consider
upgrading. Is the 4th-generation iPad better? Sure. But not by wide
enough of a margin to justify dropping an extra US$500 (or more), just a
few months after buying its predecessor.
First-time iPad buyers and owners of older iPads (original or iPad
2), though, are in for a treat. The new iPad has one of the best
displays you've seen on anything, an attractive design, and
turbo-charged performance.
Two caveats
If you're in the market for a new iPad, there are only two reasons to
balk at this 4th-generation model: the iPad mini, and the possibility
of a
new model in March.
If Apple released this iPad 4 only seven months after the iPad 3, who
says we won't see an iPad 5 in a few more months? I'm not sure if Apple
would abandon its typical iPad release slot and crunch all of its big
announcements into the (Northern Hemisphere) autumn. This model was
likely released to maximize holiday sales; a bigger update could be just
around the corner.
Then there's the
iPad mini.
Though it sorely misses the larger model's Retina Display, it sports an
airy new design, it's more portable, and holding it with one hand is
extremely comfortable. If you can tolerate its 1024 x 768 display (1/4
the pixels of the iPad 4's display), it may be a better buy than the
full-sized tablet. See our
iPad mini review for more.
This article taken from review of
Will Shanklin